01
Tell the story
Dr. Morton starts with what happened, what has changed, what you have already tried, and what you need your body to do again.
Meniscus repair
Meniscus tears: repair, trimming, rehab, or time?
Meniscus tears are common, but the right answer is not always surgery. I look at the tear pattern, arthritis, swelling, catching, locking, and what you need your knee to do before recommending a path.
Online booking in about a minuteHMSA, Medicare & other major plansHonolulu · West Oahu · Hilo · KonaTelehealth for neighbor islands
Board-certifiedFellowship-trainedFAAOS / FAAHKSRobotic hip & kneeRevision expertiseHawaii roots
How the visit works
You should leave with a clearer plan than when you arrived.
02
Look at the source
Your exam and imaging help separate arthritis, injury, implant problems, referred pain, and other causes that can feel similar.
03
Choose the next step
The plan may be therapy, bracing, injections, orthobiologics, arthroscopy, robotic surgery, revision workup, or a clear reason to wait.
Before you book
The first visit is better when the story is organized.
Joint Replacement Hawaii has always asked practical questions before the appointment because the details matter: what hurts, where it hurts, what you have tried, and what life activity you want back.
01
What are you having trouble with?
Getting in and out of a car
Getting up from a chair
Stairs
Walking long distances
Pain at night
Exercise, sports, or work
02
What are you noticing?
Swelling
Instability or giving way
Stiffness or limited motion
Catching or locking
Grinding
Difficulty bearing weight
03
What have you already tried?
Physical therapy
Brace, cane, walker, or crutches
Steroid or gel injections
PRP or BMAC questions
NSAIDs or Tylenol
Prior arthroscopy or surgery
Before you decide
The conversation I want patients to understand.
01
When I usually see patients
Patients come in after a twist, swelling, joint-line pain, catching, locking, or an MRI report that says meniscus tear. The MRI matters, but it is not the whole story.
02
What we look at together
We compare the MRI with your symptoms, X-rays, exam, arthritis level, activity goals, and whether the knee has true mechanical symptoms.
03
Your options
Some tears are treated with time, therapy, and activity changes. Some can be repaired. Some are better treated with arthroscopy to trim unstable tissue. Arthritis can change the entire conversation.
How I think through the recommendation
The decision should be explained, not handed to you.
Patients should know what would make us wait, what would make treatment reasonable, what might require more testing, and what changes recovery planning.
01
What may make us wait
- Pain is mostly arthritis, not a mechanical tear
- Symptoms are improving
- Repair would not be reliable for the tear type
02
What may make surgery reasonable
- Locking, catching, or displaced tear symptoms
- Repairable tear pattern in the right patient
- Activity goals and imaging match the exam
03
What may mean more tests
- X-rays to understand arthritis
- MRI if mechanical symptoms persist
- ACL or cartilage injury changes the plan
04
What changes recovery planning
- Repair versus trimming restrictions
- Crutches and weight-bearing limits
- Work, stairs, and activity timing
Meniscus decision guide
A meniscus tear is not the whole story.
The MRI headline matters less than how the knee behaves: catching, locking, swelling, arthritis, tear pattern, tissue quality, and what you need to get back to.
Think about 01
Can it be repaired?
Repair depends on tear location, blood supply, tissue quality, age, activity goals, and whether the knee can protect the repair.
Think about 02
Is it truly mechanical?
Catching or locking is a different story than broad arthritis pain. That difference changes whether arthroscopy is likely to help.
Think about 03
Protect the knee long term
The goal is not just to treat this month of pain. It is to preserve as much useful knee function as possible.
For informed patients
The details matter, especially when the decision is not simple.
If you are comparing surgeons, robotics, revision care, injections, or recovery plans, these are the questions I want you to feel comfortable asking.
01
Repair versus trimming
Informed patients need to know whether a tear can heal, whether arthritis is driving pain, and what restrictions follow repair.
Tear patternBlood supplyArthritis context
02
Mechanical symptoms matter
Catching, locking, swelling, and injury history matter more than the MRI headline by itself.
Symptoms match imagingArthroscopy only when usefulRecovery restrictions explained
Patient words
The trust signal should match the decision.
Patients are looking for listening, clear explanations, office kindness, and a plan that makes sense for their specific problem.
Patient trust
Sports knee patients want their confidence back.
ACL and meniscus care is about more than the MRI. It is about stability, swelling, mechanical symptoms, activity goals, and a recovery plan the patient can follow.
01
ACL reconstruction planning
02
Meniscus repair and arthroscopy guidance
03
Return-to-sport and return-to-work milestones
You may be ready to schedule if
Catching, locking, or sharp joint-line pain
Swelling after a twist or injury
MRI shows a meniscus tear
Symptoms and imaging seem to match
You want to understand repair versus trimming versus rehab
Why patients choose this practice
Sports knee, meniscus, ACL, injection, and recovery decisions are connected
MRI findings are matched to the exam and the way the knee behaves
Return-to-work, return-to-sport, and long-term joint protection are discussed together
Older patients and caregivers
Older patients and caregivers deserve a clear plan too.
Safety, medications, stairs, rides, hearing, memory, home help, and caregiver questions can change the recommendation and the recovery plan.
01
Who should come with you
Bring the person who helps with medications, rides, meals, stairs, wound checks, or remembering instructions. A second set of ears helps.
02
How to plan home safety
Think about loose rugs, bathroom setup, stairs, lighting, pets, walking aids, shower safety, and where you will sleep the first few nights.
03
When to call the office
Call for worsening wound redness, drainage, fever, severe swelling, a fall, medication confusion, or symptoms that do not match your instructions.
04
When not to wait
Chest pain, shortness of breath, fainting, stroke-like symptoms, major deformity, or dangerous symptoms need emergency care.
Helpful to bring
X-rays, MRI, CT scans, or reports if you already have them
Where the pain starts, where it travels, and what it stops you from doing
Prior injections, therapy, medications, braces, or operations
Your goals for work, walking, golf, hiking, sports, travel, and recovery
Make the visit count
Bring the story, not just the scan.
Imaging helps, but the story matters too: what changed, what you tried, what failed, and what life you want back. This is especially important for revision opinions, prior surgery, and neighbor island travel.
Recovery preview
Prepare for meniscus recovery
Meniscus recovery changes depending on repair versus trimming, crutches, motion, and activity restrictions.
Repair versus trimming
Crutches and motion
Return to activity
Patient questions
Questions I hear in the office.
Can every meniscus tear be repaired?
No. Repair depends on tear location, pattern, blood supply, tissue quality, arthritis, and whether the knee can protect the repair.
Does a meniscus tear always need surgery?
No. Many tears improve without surgery, especially when symptoms are not mechanical or arthritis is the bigger pain source.
What if I also have arthritis?
Then we have to be careful. Arthroscopy may not solve arthritis pain, even when a meniscus tear is visible on MRI.
Mahalo
You do not have to figure this out alone.
If pain, injury, arthritis, or an old implant is keeping you from life, bring your questions. Dr. Morton and the team will help you understand the problem and the next step.
Written for patients by the practice
Orthopedic guidance should be clear enough to help you make a real decision.
Dr. Paul Norio Morton created Joint Replacement Hawaii to help patients understand hip pain, knee pain, arthritis, sports injuries, robotic joint replacement, revision surgery, injections, and recovery before they come in for a visit.
